2020 Vol. 9, No. 6

Special Topic Papers: Passive Radar Technology
Given the functions and performance advantages of passive radar, this paper first reviews the research history of passive radar for more than 80 years and then examines the research progress of related key technologies, including reference signal reconstruction, multipath clutter suppression, target detection, target tracking, and passive radar imaging. On this basis, the latest research results of typical experimental systems of passive radar abroad (particularly in European countries) are presented in terms of system structures, technical parameters, and performance indices. Then this paper focuses on the Multi-Illuminator-based PAssive Radar (MIPAR) series of Wuhan University in China. The target detection results of MIPAR in different frequency bands (HF/VHF/UHF/L) are given, that show the application potential of the MIPAR system in long-range early warning and close-range high-precision monitoring. Finally, the development trends of passive radar, including the integration of multiple illuminators, system network configuration, and intelligent signal processing, are discussed. Given the functions and performance advantages of passive radar, this paper first reviews the research history of passive radar for more than 80 years and then examines the research progress of related key technologies, including reference signal reconstruction, multipath clutter suppression, target detection, target tracking, and passive radar imaging. On this basis, the latest research results of typical experimental systems of passive radar abroad (particularly in European countries) are presented in terms of system structures, technical parameters, and performance indices. Then this paper focuses on the Multi-Illuminator-based PAssive Radar (MIPAR) series of Wuhan University in China. The target detection results of MIPAR in different frequency bands (HF/VHF/UHF/L) are given, that show the application potential of the MIPAR system in long-range early warning and close-range high-precision monitoring. Finally, the development trends of passive radar, including the integration of multiple illuminators, system network configuration, and intelligent signal processing, are discussed.
Owing to their strong anti-stealth performance, good concealment and strong survivability, passive radar systems have a wide range of applications in both military and civilian fields. We propose a method of target detection for passive radar systems which is based on the characteristics of these systems and the track-before-detect concept. This method accumulates information to effectively detect weak targets with low signal-to-noise ratios and meet real-time requirements. First, we discretize the state space, then perform recursive Bayesian filtering to transfer and accumulate target-state information between multiple frames. Lastly, the information entropy is used to determine whether the target exists, thereby avoiding reliance on a prior assumption about the transition probability model between the existence and the absence of the target. This method is simple to implement and has low computational complexity and high parallelism. The experimental results indicate that the proposed method has a short running time and strong real-time performance, as well as good detection performance and robustness. Owing to their strong anti-stealth performance, good concealment and strong survivability, passive radar systems have a wide range of applications in both military and civilian fields. We propose a method of target detection for passive radar systems which is based on the characteristics of these systems and the track-before-detect concept. This method accumulates information to effectively detect weak targets with low signal-to-noise ratios and meet real-time requirements. First, we discretize the state space, then perform recursive Bayesian filtering to transfer and accumulate target-state information between multiple frames. Lastly, the information entropy is used to determine whether the target exists, thereby avoiding reliance on a prior assumption about the transition probability model between the existence and the absence of the target. This method is simple to implement and has low computational complexity and high parallelism. The experimental results indicate that the proposed method has a short running time and strong real-time performance, as well as good detection performance and robustness.
This article presents experimental results of target detection using a miniaturized multichannel passive radar system that exploits Long Term Evolution (LTE) signals. First, the advantages of LTE signals are discussed with respect to their ambiguity function. Second, both system design and field experiments are introduced. Finally, agreements between different targets and their truth obtained in the results prove the technical feasibility of using LTE signals for detecting ground and low-altitude targets via field experiments, thus forming the basis for further development of LTE-based passive radar. This article presents experimental results of target detection using a miniaturized multichannel passive radar system that exploits Long Term Evolution (LTE) signals. First, the advantages of LTE signals are discussed with respect to their ambiguity function. Second, both system design and field experiments are introduced. Finally, agreements between different targets and their truth obtained in the results prove the technical feasibility of using LTE signals for detecting ground and low-altitude targets via field experiments, thus forming the basis for further development of LTE-based passive radar.
The illuminators of passive radar based civil communication signals are densely distributed. As a result, the co-channel illuminator always interferes with the primary and reference channels, resulting in poor detection performance. To solve the aforementioned problem, an improved signal processing flow with co-channel interference suppression is proposed in this paper. First, signals from all channels were processed jointly. The direct-path wave of each illuminator was estimated using the multi-channel blind deconvolution algorithm. Then, the direct-path wave of the primary illuminator was identified as the reference signal by applying the difference in the proportion of the primary illuminator signal energy among channels. Then, the clutter of each illuminator in the primary channel was suppressed by utilizing each of the above estimated signals. Finally, the residual signal, after cancellation, was used to compute the cross-ambiguity functions with the identified direct-path wave of the primary illuminator for target detection. The improved flow can promote the cancellation ratio and reduce the bottom noise of the cross-ambiguity function and missed alarm. Co-channel interference can be effectively suppressed using the improved processing flow without changing the radar system’s hardware. The validity of the proposed method were confirmed by the results of the simulation and experiment. The illuminators of passive radar based civil communication signals are densely distributed. As a result, the co-channel illuminator always interferes with the primary and reference channels, resulting in poor detection performance. To solve the aforementioned problem, an improved signal processing flow with co-channel interference suppression is proposed in this paper. First, signals from all channels were processed jointly. The direct-path wave of each illuminator was estimated using the multi-channel blind deconvolution algorithm. Then, the direct-path wave of the primary illuminator was identified as the reference signal by applying the difference in the proportion of the primary illuminator signal energy among channels. Then, the clutter of each illuminator in the primary channel was suppressed by utilizing each of the above estimated signals. Finally, the residual signal, after cancellation, was used to compute the cross-ambiguity functions with the identified direct-path wave of the primary illuminator for target detection. The improved flow can promote the cancellation ratio and reduce the bottom noise of the cross-ambiguity function and missed alarm. Co-channel interference can be effectively suppressed using the improved processing flow without changing the radar system’s hardware. The validity of the proposed method were confirmed by the results of the simulation and experiment.
Radar and its countermeasure technology promote each other and make continuous progress in the development of radar system. Recently, passive radar systems have received extensive attention by research institutes at home and abroad owing to their excellent performance. Moreover, the relevant technologies have been developed rapidly with some equipment being placed into operation. However, there is a lack of research on the jamming technology for this new-type radar. Here, we provide an analysis of the signal component based on the structure of radiation source signal. Next, we propose a passive radar jamming method based on the characteristic of signal structure, taking digital broadcasting television-based passive radar as an example. In the proposed passive radar jamming model, the jamming signal produces an interference peak or interference band in the range-Doppler map. These interference peaks or bands effectively mask the target and lead to a false track, thereby achieving the goal of jamming the passive radar system. Both the characteristics of the jamming signal and the effectiveness of the jamming method are verified by the simulation results. Moreover, the results presented here establish the foundation for practical application of a passive radar jamming signal. The proposed method could be applied into both the digital broadcasting television-based passive radar at home and abroad as well as other types of passive radar. Radar and its countermeasure technology promote each other and make continuous progress in the development of radar system. Recently, passive radar systems have received extensive attention by research institutes at home and abroad owing to their excellent performance. Moreover, the relevant technologies have been developed rapidly with some equipment being placed into operation. However, there is a lack of research on the jamming technology for this new-type radar. Here, we provide an analysis of the signal component based on the structure of radiation source signal. Next, we propose a passive radar jamming method based on the characteristic of signal structure, taking digital broadcasting television-based passive radar as an example. In the proposed passive radar jamming model, the jamming signal produces an interference peak or interference band in the range-Doppler map. These interference peaks or bands effectively mask the target and lead to a false track, thereby achieving the goal of jamming the passive radar system. Both the characteristics of the jamming signal and the effectiveness of the jamming method are verified by the simulation results. Moreover, the results presented here establish the foundation for practical application of a passive radar jamming signal. The proposed method could be applied into both the digital broadcasting television-based passive radar at home and abroad as well as other types of passive radar.
Reviews

Passive localization technology, which intercepts emitter signals and passively determines their positions, has important value in fields such as electronic reconnaissance and search and rescue. The traditional passive localization technology approach, i.e., cross-bearing, time difference of arrival, and frequency difference of arrival, requires two steps to estimate the emitter position—estimating the parameters related to the positions and then solving the emitter positions based on the previously estimated parameters. This process results in loss of information and difficulty with data association, and requires high system sensitivity. In recent years, a Direct Position Determination (DPD) method was developed that obtains the emitter positions directly by processing the original sampled signals and requires no estimation of intermediate parameters. This method is robust, achieves high performance with a low signal-to-noise ratio, and requires no parameter association. In this paper, we present a comprehensive summary of existing research on DPD and an overall introduction of DPD, including typical DPD methods based on different information types, DPD of special signals, high-resolution high-accuracy DPD, fast DPD algorithms, and the calibration technology used to address DPD model errors. We also consider the future outlook for DPD.

Passive localization technology, which intercepts emitter signals and passively determines their positions, has important value in fields such as electronic reconnaissance and search and rescue. The traditional passive localization technology approach, i.e., cross-bearing, time difference of arrival, and frequency difference of arrival, requires two steps to estimate the emitter position—estimating the parameters related to the positions and then solving the emitter positions based on the previously estimated parameters. This process results in loss of information and difficulty with data association, and requires high system sensitivity. In recent years, a Direct Position Determination (DPD) method was developed that obtains the emitter positions directly by processing the original sampled signals and requires no estimation of intermediate parameters. This method is robust, achieves high performance with a low signal-to-noise ratio, and requires no parameter association. In this paper, we present a comprehensive summary of existing research on DPD and an overall introduction of DPD, including typical DPD methods based on different information types, DPD of special signals, high-resolution high-accuracy DPD, fast DPD algorithms, and the calibration technology used to address DPD model errors. We also consider the future outlook for DPD.

Specific emitter identification is a technique of extracting the radio frequency fingerprints of the received electromagnetic signal only using external feature measurements to determine the specific emitter that transmits the signal. In recent years, the related theories and practical applications of specific emitter identification have been continuously improved, and research on radio frequency fingerprinting feature extraction methods has made great progress. Based on the domestic and foreign academic achievements, this paper systematically reviews the status quo of the fingerprint feature extraction method of specific emitter identification. In addition, a new feature classification framework is proposed based on the inherent logic of fingerprint feature extraction. The classification framework combines the description characteristics of different radio frequency fingerprinting features and the correlation between them. It divides the existing radio frequency features into two main categories: direct measurement features and dimensionality reduction transform features, which have three levels. Finally, this paper analyzes and explores several potential research directions of fingerprint feature extraction, aiming to benefit the research and application of specific radiation source identification. Specific emitter identification is a technique of extracting the radio frequency fingerprints of the received electromagnetic signal only using external feature measurements to determine the specific emitter that transmits the signal. In recent years, the related theories and practical applications of specific emitter identification have been continuously improved, and research on radio frequency fingerprinting feature extraction methods has made great progress. Based on the domestic and foreign academic achievements, this paper systematically reviews the status quo of the fingerprint feature extraction method of specific emitter identification. In addition, a new feature classification framework is proposed based on the inherent logic of fingerprint feature extraction. The classification framework combines the description characteristics of different radio frequency fingerprinting features and the correlation between them. It divides the existing radio frequency features into two main categories: direct measurement features and dimensionality reduction transform features, which have three levels. Finally, this paper analyzes and explores several potential research directions of fingerprint feature extraction, aiming to benefit the research and application of specific radiation source identification.
Papers
Aircraft wake are a couple of counter-rotating vortices generated by a flying aircraft, which can be very hazardous to a follower aircraft. The detection of it is regarded as a key issue for airport capacity improvement and air traffic safety management. To this end, we constructed a Lidar detection based aircraft wake vortex parameter-retrieval system, which can be used to retrieve the vortex-core positions and circulations from detected data. Furthermore, dynamics, scattering and Lidar echo simulation modules were built to validate the parameter-retrieval algorithms. Results show that the proposed system performs well and runs steadily, which can serve as a good tool for aircraft wake vortex characterization, prediction, and is very helpful to establish dynamic wake separation in air traffic management. Aircraft wake are a couple of counter-rotating vortices generated by a flying aircraft, which can be very hazardous to a follower aircraft. The detection of it is regarded as a key issue for airport capacity improvement and air traffic safety management. To this end, we constructed a Lidar detection based aircraft wake vortex parameter-retrieval system, which can be used to retrieve the vortex-core positions and circulations from detected data. Furthermore, dynamics, scattering and Lidar echo simulation modules were built to validate the parameter-retrieval algorithms. Results show that the proposed system performs well and runs steadily, which can serve as a good tool for aircraft wake vortex characterization, prediction, and is very helpful to establish dynamic wake separation in air traffic management.
Two-Dimensional (2-D) autofocus is an important guarantee for high-resolution imaging of airborne Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) under high maneuvering conditions. The existing 2-D autofocus approaches for bistatic SAR blindly estimate the phase error and do not fully utilize the prior knowledge on phase structure. In this paper, a new interpretation of the Polar Format Algorithm (PFA) for general bistatic SAR imaging is presented. From the viewpoint of Residual Cell Migration (RCM), PFA is converted into 2-D decoupling. By utilizing this new formulation, we analyze the effect of range and azimuth resampling on the residual 2-D phase error and reveal the inherent structure characteristics of the residual 2-D phase error in the wavenumber domain. The 2-D phase error estimation can reduce to one dimensional azimuth phase error estimation. Based on this prior knowledge, a structure-aided 2-D autofocus approach is proposed. Meanwhile, the information of all the data is fully excavated by averaging sub-band data when the azimuth phase error is being estimated. Compared with the existing algorithms, both the parameter estimation precision and computational efficiency are significantly improved. Experimental results clearly demonstrate the correctness of the theoretical analysis and the effectiveness of the proposed method. Two-Dimensional (2-D) autofocus is an important guarantee for high-resolution imaging of airborne Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) under high maneuvering conditions. The existing 2-D autofocus approaches for bistatic SAR blindly estimate the phase error and do not fully utilize the prior knowledge on phase structure. In this paper, a new interpretation of the Polar Format Algorithm (PFA) for general bistatic SAR imaging is presented. From the viewpoint of Residual Cell Migration (RCM), PFA is converted into 2-D decoupling. By utilizing this new formulation, we analyze the effect of range and azimuth resampling on the residual 2-D phase error and reveal the inherent structure characteristics of the residual 2-D phase error in the wavenumber domain. The 2-D phase error estimation can reduce to one dimensional azimuth phase error estimation. Based on this prior knowledge, a structure-aided 2-D autofocus approach is proposed. Meanwhile, the information of all the data is fully excavated by averaging sub-band data when the azimuth phase error is being estimated. Compared with the existing algorithms, both the parameter estimation precision and computational efficiency are significantly improved. Experimental results clearly demonstrate the correctness of the theoretical analysis and the effectiveness of the proposed method.
Discussions
With the emergence of stealth and jamming technology, traditional radar systems are facing great challenges in terms of innovation, number, and energy. It is necessary to develop novel detection systems, explore the initiative of cooperative detection, and utilize the dimensions of information to adapt to new air defense operations in the future. In this study, a new radar system, communicational radar, is proposed. The radar detection ability under the conditions of long-range and strong confrontation can be significantly improved by embedding synchronization information such as the transmitter position, the antenna direction, and the launch time of the emission into the waveform; the embedded information can then be extracted for target detection, reorganization, interference suppression, and multi-target identification. The proposed system is illustrated from the aspects of architecture, detection principle, and performance analysis. With the emergence of stealth and jamming technology, traditional radar systems are facing great challenges in terms of innovation, number, and energy. It is necessary to develop novel detection systems, explore the initiative of cooperative detection, and utilize the dimensions of information to adapt to new air defense operations in the future. In this study, a new radar system, communicational radar, is proposed. The radar detection ability under the conditions of long-range and strong confrontation can be significantly improved by embedding synchronization information such as the transmitter position, the antenna direction, and the launch time of the emission into the waveform; the embedded information can then be extracted for target detection, reorganization, interference suppression, and multi-target identification. The proposed system is illustrated from the aspects of architecture, detection principle, and performance analysis.